Why Do People Bully and Coerce Others? Offerings & Solutions by Nik Shah

Introduction

Bullying and coercion—whether in schools, workplaces, homes, or online—are pervasive forms of aggression that can leave lasting scars on their targets. These behaviors involve exerting power over another individual to control, intimidate, or degrade them. Although bullying is often associated with children and teens, it exists in every corner of adult life as well: from dictatorial bosses to intimate partner abuse to cyber-harassment.

At first glance, bullying and coercion may seem like senseless cruelty. Yet, behind these harmful actions, individuals often harbor psychological needs and drives that push them toward such behaviors. Understanding the root causes of bullying and coercion is a critical step in preventing them—and in creating healthier, more respectful communities.

In this article, we’ll examine five primary reasons why people bully and coerce others, assigning each reason a percent attribution that reflects its relative frequency or importance:

1. Insecurity & Low Self-Esteem (30%)

2. Desire for Power & Dominance (25%)

3. Cultural & Learned Behavior (20%)

4. Group Dynamics & Social Pressures (15%)

5. Pathological or Personality Factors (10%)

We will then explore practical solutions aligned to these same percentages—actions individuals, families, organizations, and societies can take to mitigate bullying and coercion at its core. By the end, you’ll gain a deeper understanding of these toxic behaviors and a toolkit for addressing them more effectively.

Part I: The Problem—Why People Bully and Coerce

1. Insecurity & Low Self-Esteem (30%)

At the top of our list, with 30% attribution, is insecurity and low self-esteem. While it might appear paradoxical, many bullies feel vulnerable and powerless deep down. Their aggression serves as a coping mechanism to mask personal fears, anxieties, or feelings of inferiority.

Key Components

1. Projection: Someone struggling with their own perceived weaknesses may “project” these insecurities onto others, using bullying to redirect attention away from their vulnerabilities.

2. Compensation Mechanism: By belittling or coercing a target, bullies attempt to elevate their self-image. Momentarily, they feel stronger or more valued.

3. Negative Self-Concept: Chronic negative self-talk can prime individuals to lash out. Their internal dialogue might be “I’m unworthy,” so they target others to build a fragile sense of power.

Real-World Examples

• School Bullies: Adolescents who struggle academically or socially may pick on peers to seem confident or superior.

• Workplace Put-Downs: Colleagues who fear they’re underqualified might demean new hires or spread rumors to look more competent.

• Online Harassment: Trolls on social media platforms often wrestle with personal insecurities, finding fleeting reassurance in provoking others.

Consequences

• Deepening Self-Loathing: Although bullying temporarily boosts a bully’s ego, guilt or further shame often surfaces later, exacerbating insecurities.

• Victim Harm: Targets experience anxiety, stress, and reduced self-esteem, which can linger for years.

• Toxic Environments: Classrooms, workplaces, or communities rife with insecure bullies struggle with tension and lack of trust.

2. Desire for Power & Dominance (25%)

With 25% attribution, power—and the thrill of exerting it—fuels a large portion of bullying incidents. Some individuals find satisfaction in controlling others, viewing relationships through hierarchical lenses: “winners” vs. “losers.”

Key Components

1. Sense of Importance: By making others submit, bullies feel important or validated.

2. Control Dynamic: Coercion allows them to orchestrate outcomes that favor themselves—whether it’s controlling social circles, shaping workplace decisions, or dictating family interactions.

3. Historical & Cultural Precedents: Entire societies have been structured around power hierarchies, with those at the top maintaining status through intimidation.

Real-World Examples

• Authoritarian Managers: Supervisors who publicly humiliate employees or withhold promotions unless subordinates comply with their every demand.

• Political or Militant Coercion: Regimes that suppress dissent or free speech through threats, imprisonment, or violence.

• Familial Abuse: A controlling spouse exerting financial or emotional manipulation over their partner.

Consequences

• Cycle of Violence: Once power is established through bullying or coercion, it can escalate—leading to more severe abuses.

• Damage to Morale & Productivity: In workplaces, team members become disengaged or fearful, hindering innovation and collaboration.

• Reinforcement of Oppressive Systems: Societies with rampant power-driven bullying perpetuate inequality and distrust.

3. Cultural & Learned Behavior (20%)

At 20%, cultural and learned factors play a substantial role. In many environments, bullying or coercive tactics are normalized—implicitly or overtly—and passed down through generations or within peer groups.

Key Components

1. Family Modeling: Children who witness aggression at home often internalize it, learning that intimidation or force is an acceptable conflict-resolution strategy.

2. Societal Norms: Certain cultures or communities might equate toughness with respect, dismissing bullying as “boys will be boys,” or a rite of passage.

3. Media Influence: Popular shows, music, or online content sometimes glamorize domineering personalities, reinforcing the notion that bullying is edgy or cool.

Real-World Examples

• School Traditions: Hazing rituals in fraternities or sports teams, preserved under the guise of bonding or tradition, perpetuate a cycle of abuse.

• Intergenerational Trauma: Families in which parents used coercive discipline can unknowingly teach kids to replicate that behavior.

• Online Culture: Certain subcultures on the internet celebrate “roasting” or humiliating others for entertainment, blurring the line between humor and harassment.

Consequences

• Normalization of Violence: Once embedded, cultural acceptance of bullying stifles accountability, as few question or challenge established traditions.

• Perpetual Cycle: Victims of cultural bullying might later become bullies themselves, continuing the pattern.

• Community Division: Ongoing acceptance of coercion fractures communities, sowing fear and resentment among members.

4. Group Dynamics & Social Pressures (15%)

With 15% attribution, group dynamics and peer influence can spur bullying and coercion. Individuals who might otherwise not bully can be swayed by peer approval, group loyalty, or fear of ostracism.

Key Components

1. Conformity: People adopt group behaviors—even if those behaviors are harmful—to fit in or be seen as part of the “in-crowd.”

2. Mob Mentality: When a group collectively bullies an outsider, individual members may feel less personal responsibility.

3. Peer Reinforcement: Bullies often receive encouragement from bystanders who laugh, clap, or remain silent, inadvertently rewarding aggression.

Real-World Examples

• Cliques in Schools: Popular groups might target less popular students to reinforce their social hierarchy.

• Workplace Cliques: Staffers who side with a dominant coworker or manager, collectively shunning or ridiculing another employee.

• Cyber-Mobbing: Online communities that gang up on a specific user, bombarding them with insults or threats.

Consequences

• Rapid Escalation: Group-based bullying can escalate quickly, leading to severe abuse, as individuals egg each other on.

• Collective Guilt: Once the group’s actions are scrutinized, members may experience regret or shame—but also confusion about their roles.

• Damage to Social Fabric: Entire cohorts or teams can be tainted, with trust eroding among everyone involved.

5. Pathological or Personality Factors (10%)

Lastly, at 10%, a subset of bullies operate from deep-seated psychological or personality disorders. While not everyone who bullies has a diagnosable condition, those with certain traits—like extreme narcissism or antisocial tendencies—can be more prone to cruelty.

Key Components

1. Antisocial Personality Disorder: Individuals with a disregard for others’ rights or feelings may enjoy manipulating or harming them for personal gain.

2. Psychopathy & Sadism: Some feel pleasure from causing distress, lacking remorse or empathy.

3. Narcissistic Grandiosity: A person with an inflated self-image might bully those who fail to cater to their ego.

Real-World Examples

• Serial Abusers: Repeatedly targeting new victims, deriving satisfaction from each act of coercion or manipulation.

• Corporate Exploiters: High-functioning individuals in leadership who use emotional intimidation to achieve objectives without guilt.

• Gang Leaders: Charismatic but ruthless figures who exploit followers’ loyalty to perpetuate violence.

Consequences

• Serious Harm to Victims: Targets can suffer long-term trauma, depression, or PTSD.

• Criminal Justice Involvement: Severe cases may result in legal actions, incarceration, or mandated therapy.

• Community-Wide Fear: Pathological bullies can destabilize entire environments if unchecked.

Part II: The Solutions—Addressing & Preventing Bullying and Coercion

Now that we’ve outlined the causes, we’ll propose practical strategies—aligned with the same percentages—to tackle bullying at its root. These solutions range from personal interventions to broader systemic reforms.

1. Mitigating Insecurity & Low Self-Esteem (30%)

Because insecurity is the largest single driver, we must foster emotional resilience, positive self-concept, and healthy coping strategies for potential bullies and bystanders alike.

A. Confidence & Self-Esteem Programs (15%)

• Counseling & Therapy: Schools and workplaces can provide accessible mental health support, helping individuals address personal anxieties or self-worth deficits.

• Positive Feedback Loops: Encourage peer recognition for genuine achievements rather than put-downs. For example, in a classroom, students earn praise for collaboration rather than dominating behaviors.

• Mentorship & Role Modeling: Pair younger or vulnerable individuals with mentors who exemplify empathy and self-assurance.

B. Emotional Regulation Skills (10%)

• Workshops on Anger & Stress Management: Teaching potential bullies how to manage negative emotions without lashing out.

• Mindfulness & Relaxation Techniques: Individuals learn to reflect on their insecurities, respond calmly to triggers, and break the impulsive cycle of aggression.

C. Reframing Failure & Criticism (5%)

• Growth Mindset Education: Show that mistakes or weaknesses aren’t signs of unworthiness. This perspective reduces the impetus for compensatory bullying.

• Constructive Feedback Culture: At work or school, praise effort over innate ability, emphasizing improvement rather than blame when challenges arise.

2. Counteracting the Desire for Power & Dominance (25%)

To curb power-driven bullying, structures and policies must limit opportunities for unrestrained authority and highlight accountability.

A. Clear Anti-Bullying Policies (15%)

• Institutional Guidelines: From schools to businesses, spelled-out consequences for harassment or intimidation deter those seeking power through bullying.

• Whistleblower & Reporting Mechanisms: Encourage bystanders or victims to report incidents safely, ensuring anonymity if needed.

• Zero Tolerance vs. Growth Approach: While some serious infractions warrant firm punishment, offer restorative options (like mediation) for minor power plays, aiming to reform behavior rather than just punishing it.

B. Checks and Balances (5%)

• Distributed Leadership: Rather than one person holding all authority, rotate leadership roles or involve committees in major decisions, diffusing the monopoly of power.

• Transparent Decision-Making: In workplaces, require that managers justify major personnel moves or disciplinary actions publicly or to an oversight body, preventing arbitrary intimidation.

C. Promoting Collaborative Skills (5%)

• Team-Building Exercises: Group tasks emphasizing cooperation over competition. For instance, workplaces can celebrate shared successes, undermining the impetus to climb the ladder by stepping on colleagues.

• Conflict Mediation Training: Teach managers and employees how to settle disputes without resorting to coercion or intimidation.

3. Reforming Cultural & Learned Behaviors (20%)

With 20% dedicated to cultural norms, the solution demands long-term education and consistent modeling of respectful behaviors.

A. Family & Community Outreach (10%)

• Parenting Workshops: Educate parents on non-coercive discipline strategies, helping them model constructive conflict resolution.

• Public Awareness Campaigns: Billboards, radio spots, or social media initiatives that promote empathy and denounce bullying, shifting collective attitudes over time.

B. Updating Traditions & Rituals (5%)

• Alternative Rites of Passage: Replace hazing practices with bonding activities that emphasize mentorship and support—e.g., philanthropic events or skill-building retreats.

• Media & Entertainment: Advocate for film, TV, and game industries to depict healthy conflict resolutions more often, challenging the glorification of bullies or tyrants.

C. Incorporating Anti-Bullying Curriculum (5%)

• School Lessons: From kindergarten onward, programs that teach empathy, diversity, and the harms of bullying.

• Continuous Reinforcement: Not just a one-off assembly—integrate relevant topics into literature, social studies, or group projects.

4. Transforming Group Dynamics & Social Pressures (15%)

Because 15% of bullying stems from group contexts, solutions must empower bystanders and reshape peer norms.

A. Bystander Intervention Training (7%)

• Role-Playing & Scenario-Based Exercises: Teach students or employees how to safely intervene when witnessing bullying—e.g., diffusing tension, redirecting group attention, or privately checking on the victim.

• Encourage Active Upstanders: Reward those who step in to stop cruelty, reinforcing the message that it’s admirable to protect vulnerable peers.

B. Creating Inclusive Group Identities (5%)

• Team-Building Focused on Shared Goals: For example, sports teams can be reoriented toward mutual success rather than establishing a harsh pecking order.

• Open Communication Channels: Encourage daily or weekly check-ins in teams or classes, where group members can air concerns about internal power struggles.

C. Social Accountability Systems (3%)

• Anonymous Group Feedback: Provide platforms where members can rate group atmosphere or identify bullying trends, prompting leaders to address issues quickly.

• Peer Mediation Programs: Train selected students or employees as mediators who help resolve conflicts before they escalate into bullying.

5. Managing Pathological or Personality Factors (10%)

Finally, for the 10% who bully due to underlying personality disorders or pathological traits, targeted mental health interventions and vigilant oversight are critical.

A. Early Identification & Therapy (5%)

• Screening & Counseling: If signs of persistent aggression, lack of empathy, or manipulative behavior emerge, provide psychological evaluations and specialized therapy (e.g., cognitive-behavioral therapy).

• School & Workplace Support: Counselors who can handle more severe aggression or consistent defiance, steering individuals toward professional help.

B. Legal & Disciplinary Mechanisms (3%)

• Criminal Justice Approaches: In cases of physical assault or severe emotional abuse, law enforcement involvement may be necessary.

• Strict Workplace Policies: For employees who repeatedly violate conduct guidelines, progressive discipline or termination might be warranted to safeguard the broader team.

C. Continuous Monitoring & Rehabilitation (2%)

• Post-Treatment Follow-Ups: Once a person with antisocial traits completes therapy, maintain check-ins to ensure they’re not reverting to harmful behaviors.

• Support Systems: Mentors, sponsors, or community groups that assist in reintegrating individuals who had pathological aggression issues into pro-social roles.

Part III: Practical Scenarios—Applying Solutions

Below are two illustrative examples demonstrating how these strategies might unfold in real-life contexts.

Scenario 1: High School Bullying

1. Context: A 15-year-old named Alex frequently humiliates a quieter classmate, Sam, during lunch, joined by a group of peers who egg Alex on. Teachers suspect Alex struggles with family troubles. Sam dreads attending school.

2. Causes:

   • Insecurity (30%): Alex has poor academic performance, feeling overshadowed by siblings at home.

   • Peer Pressure (15%): Friends laugh at Alex’s digs, reinforcing the behavior.

3. Solutions:

   • Insecurity Intervention (15% of solutions): Alex meets weekly with the school counselor to work on self-esteem, goal-setting, and learning healthy ways to cope with stress.

   • Bystander Training (7% of solutions): Peers attend a short workshop on recognizing bullying. Some begin quietly signaling disapproval or standing by Sam, eroding Alex’s audience.

   • Restorative Discipline (Conflict & Accountability): Instead of suspension, the school arranges a guided mediation session. Alex learns about Sam’s emotional distress, leading to empathy and a commitment to stop harassing.

Scenario 2: Workplace Coercion by a Manager

1. Context: A department head, Jenna, routinely threatens junior employees with bad performance reviews if they don’t work overtime without compensation. Morale is plummeting, and employees are afraid to report the issue.

2. Causes:

   • Desire for Power (25%): Jenna equates controlling subordinates with successful management.

   • Cultural Norm (20%): The company never enforced labor laws strictly, allowing a “tough boss” image to persist.

3. Solutions:

   • Clear Anti-Bullying Policy (15%—Power): The HR department clarifies that any intimidation tactics violate company rules and can lead to disciplinary action.

   • Ethical Culture Shift (Cultural/ Learned Behavior—10%): Leadership implements training sessions highlighting collaborative leadership methods, praising managers who support staff well-being.

   • Whistleblower Mechanism: An anonymous hotline is established, so employees can report Jenna’s behavior securely, prompting an official inquiry and corrective measures.

Part IV: Common Pitfalls & How to Overcome Them

Even with well-intentioned interventions, addressing bullying often faces obstacles. Below are typical pitfalls and recommendations:

1. Overemphasis on Punishment Alone

   • Issue: Severe penalties might deter some bullies but fail to address the underlying issues (insecurity, cultural norms).

   • Solution: Blend accountability with restorative practices—counseling, skill-building, or therapy—to encourage genuine change.

2. Neglecting Mental Health Services

   • Issue: Pathological bullies or those with deep insecurities require professional help. Simply labeling them as “bad apples” misses the chance for rehabilitation.

   • Solution: Ensure mental health support is accessible, from student counseling to employee assistance programs.

3. Bystander Apathy

   • Issue: Peers often remain silent out of fear or complacency, inadvertently emboldening bullies.

   • Solution: Emphasize bystander responsibility via training. Reward or acknowledge those who stand up against bullying.

4. Lack of Ongoing Support

   • Issue: One-time workshops or short-lived policies fade quickly, letting old bullying patterns resurface.

   • Solution: Integrate anti-bullying initiatives into routine organizational or school culture—ongoing training, regular policy reviews, leadership reinforcement.

5. Focusing on Symptoms Instead of Root Causes

   • Issue: Addressing only visible bullying incidents ignores the social, cultural, and psychological drivers behind them.

   • Solution: Conduct root-cause analyses—if a certain clique fosters exclusion, or if a manager’s style is consistently coercive, structural changes are needed.

Part V: Conclusion—Fostering Respectful and Supportive Environments

Bullying and coercion are complex, often emerging from insecurity, power-seeking, harmful traditions, group pressures, or pathological traits. By breaking down these root causes into:

1. Insecurity & Low Self-Esteem (30%)

2. Desire for Power & Dominance (25%)

3. Cultural & Learned Behavior (20%)

4. Group Dynamics & Social Pressures (15%)

5. Pathological or Personality Factors (10%)

we can see that each realm demands its own solutions.

• Insecurity calls for robust emotional support and self-esteem development.

• Power Dynamics require clear structures, policies, and balanced leadership.

• Cultural & Learned Norms must be reexamined, replacing abusive traditions with healthy ones.

• Group Pressures can be tackled via bystander empowerment and peer accountability.

• Pathological Factors necessitate mental health interventions and, when necessary, legal or disciplinary action.

Progress Through Collaboration

Real, lasting change unfolds when individuals, institutions, and communities collaborate:

• Individuals can seek help to address insecurities or abusive tendencies, practice assertiveness skills, and stand up for others.

• Families must model conflict-resolution and compassion from early childhood, discouraging violence as a solution.

• Schools and workplaces thrive by implementing anti-bullying curricula, transparent reporting systems, and continuous professional development focused on empathy and leadership.

• Governments can enforce policies against harassment and discrimination, ensuring perpetrators face consequences while also funding supportive programs.

The Long-Term Vision

A world with reduced bullying and coercion is one where people feel psychologically safe, validated, and empowered to speak or act without fear of intimidation. Cultivating such environments demands persistent effort—tracking improvement, refining policies, and adapting to new societal challenges (like cyberbullying or virtual workplaces).

Yet every step—be it a single teacher embracing conflict-resolution techniques, an HR manager adopting a no-harassment policy, or a group of friends deciding not to tolerate put-down humor—contributes to dismantling the scaffolding that props up bullying. Over time, these collective shifts can significantly reduce the prevalence and impact of bullying, creating supportive networks where no one needs to dominate others to feel secure or valuable.

By acknowledging and addressing insecurity, power-lust, cultural influence, group pressure, and pathological personality factors, communities stand a genuine chance of dislodging bullying and coercion from their social fabric. Such progress not only uplifts individuals but also enriches entire systems—schools, workplaces, families, and beyond—paving the way for more respectful, humane, and collaborative relationships.

Similar Articles

1. Why Do People Cheat Unethically? A Deep Dive into the Psychology, Motivations & Solutions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

2. Why Do People Bully and Coerce Others? Offerings & Solutions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

3. Why Are People Hypocrites? Understanding the Psychology, Motivations & Solutions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

4. Why Do People Learn at the Expense of Others? Overview & Solutions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

5. Why Do People Impersonate, Steal, or Copy Others’ Ideas? Discovery & Answers by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

6. Why Do People in Power Commit Random Acts of Cruelty? Motives & Solutions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

7. Why Do People Act with Nefarious Motives? An Exploration with Solutions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

8. Why Do People Impose Their Causes and Purposes on You Without Permission? A Comprehensive Exploration with Percent Attributions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

9. Nik Shah: Understanding Sadistic Behaviors in Business and Leadership | Nik Shah

10. Why Do People Blame/Fault Others? A Comprehensive Exploration with Percent Attributions by Nik Shah | Nik Shah

Discover More

• Ethics, Philosophy & Social Impact

• Psychology & Human Behavior

• Topics Overview

• Home

• Nik Shah's Digital Presence

Contributing Authors

Nanthaphon Yingyongsuk, Sean Shah, Gulab Mirchandani, Darshan Shah, Kranti Shah, John DeMinico, Rajeev Chabria, Rushil Shah, Francis Wesley, Sony Shah, Pory Yingyongsuk, Saksid Yingyongsuk, Nattanai Yingyongsuk, Theeraphat Yingyongsuk, Subun Yingyongsuk, Dilip Mirchandaniattanai Yingyongsuk, Theeraphat Yingyongsuk, Subun Yingyongsuk, Dilip Mirchandani